1st Feb, 2008

The Test and Results

These videos were downloaded from United Streaming, imported into iMovie and then exported using several different compression settings. The goal was to see the different buffering rates versus the quality of video.

mv4.jpg MV4 Format

File size = 7mb

h264.jpg MPEG-4 @H.264

File size = 2.2mb

h264.jpg MPEG-4 @intermediate

File size = 2.5mb

h264.jpg MPEG-4 @basic

File size = 684kb

I think in general, the MV4 took the longest to buffer. With a larger video, I can see where this will run into problems. At 7mb verus 2.2 (for H.264) it is more than 3x the file size. However, the clarity of the MV4 video versus the H.264 is not that much more remarkable.

The intermediate level degrades a bit more from the H.264 compression, but oddly is larger in size. However, it seemed to load a bit faster in my computer’s cache.

The basic settings degrade the file too much. It is the smallest file size and loads almost instantly in the computer’s cache. However, I think the tradeoff is just too great.

My recommendations: for the type of videos produced by the district, I believe exporting the file as an MPEG-4 using the H.264 compression rate seems to be the most optimal format.

 
icon for podpress  Saved for iPod - MV4 format [1:23m]: Play Now | Play in Popup

Exported from iMovie 6 using the Share > iPod automatic settings.

 
icon for podpress  MPEG-4 H.264 [1:23m]: Play Now | Play in Popup

Eported from iMovie 6 using the following settings:

Save as QuickTime using Expert Settings
Movie to MPEG-4
Broadband medium

Under Video…
Data Rate: 220
File Size: 320 x 240
Frame Rate: 15

 
icon for podpress  MPEG-4 Intermediate [1:23m]: Play Now | Play in Popup

1st Feb, 2008

MPEG-4 Basic Settings

 
icon for podpress  MPEG-4 Basic Settings [1:23m]: Play Now | Play in Popup

Page 2 of 10«12345»...Last »